SSAT SSAT
 
 
Abstracts Only
SSAT residents Corner
Find SSAT on Facebook SSAT YouTube Channel Follow SSAT on Twitter
SSAT
 
2008 Annual Meeting Posters


Risk of Leak After Laparoscopic Versus Open Bowel Anastomosis
Galal S. El-Gazzaz*, Daniel P. Geisler, Tracy L. Hull
Colorectal surgery, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH

Purpose: Anastomotic leak after colorectal surgery is a major complication that is associated with sepsis, prolonged hospitalization, and increased morbidity and mortality. The aim of this study was to investigate the safety of laparoscopic surgery (LS) as reflected by the anastomotic leak rate compared to open surgery (OS) for colorectal resective procedures.
Methods: From 2000 through 2007, all data relative to 4774 patients undergoing colorectal resective procedures with anastomosis (1516 laparoscopic and 3258 open) were prospectively recorded and retrospectively reviewed from IRB approved databases. Patients were equally matched with regards to site of anastomosis, pathology, date of surgery, age, gender, and BMI. The incidence of anastomotic leak was compared between the two groups according to location of bowel anastomosis, primary diagnosis, and year of surgery.
Results: There was no significant difference in anastomotic leak rate between the two groups: 2.3% of the LS group (N=35) versus 2.1% of the OS group (N=67) (p=0.57). With regards to the site of anastomosis, there was no significant difference in anastomotic leak rate between the two groups: right colectomy (p=0.32) and left colectomy (p=0.79). There was no significant difference in leak rate between the two groups when the operation was performed for cancer (p=0.6) or diverticulitis (p=1). There was a significant difference in anastomotic leak rate when the primary diagnosis was Crohn’s disease: 5.3% of the LS group versus 1.8% of the OS group (p=0.002).
Conclusions: Laparoscopic colorectal surgery is not associated with a higher risk of anastomotic leaks. The incidence of anastomotic leaks in Crohn’s patients may be higher when the procedure is done laparoscopically and needs to be studied further.

Variables Overall Colorectal resection with anastomosis Anastomotic bowel leak P Value
lap open lap open
Total number 4774 1516 3258 35(2.3%) 67(2.1%) P=0.57
Age (Mean±SD) 55.8±17.4 51.97 ± 16.07 55.14 ± 16.62 P=0.89
BMI (Mean±SD) 27.8±6.2 27.39 +/- 6.03 28.43 +/- 6.54 P=0.25
Diagnosis Cancer 2162 (45.3%) 282 (18.6%) 1880 (57.7%) 2.8% 2.3% P=0.6
Crohn's 1412 (29.6%) 247 (16.3%) 1165 (35.8%) 5.3% 1.8% P=0.002
Diverticulitis 588 (12.3%) 375 (24.7%) 213 (6.5%) 1.3% 0.94% P=1
Others 612 (12.8%) 612 (40.4%) 0 (0%) 1.5% 0%
Years 2000-20003 2822 (59.1%) 681 (44.9%) 2141 (65.7%) 3.9% 2.9% P=0.51
2004-2004 1952 (40.9%) 835 (55.1%) 1117 (34.3%) 3.6% 2.0% P=0.55
Site Right 987 (20.7%) 343 (22.6%) 644 (19.8%) 3.8% 2.6% P=0.32
Left 1951 (40.9%) 743 (49.0%) 1208 (37.1%) 2.4% 2.2% P=0.79
other 1836 (38.5%) 430 (28.4%) 1406 (43.2%) 1.7% 1.2% P=0.23


 

 
Home | Contact SSAT