# 2332 Laparoscopic, Open and Handport-Assisted Laparoscopic
Roux-En-Y Gastric Bypass - a Comparative Study.
Sven Os Gustavsson, Magnus Sundbom, Agneta Westling,
Uppsala, Sweden
The efficacy of Roux-en-y Gastric bypass (RGBP) in morbid obesity is well
documented. We have investigated the role of minimally invasive surgical
techniques for performing RGBP. In the first part of the study, 51 patients
(48 females, median age 34) with morbid obesity (BMI 42 kg/m2) were
randomly allocated to either laparoscopy (n = 30) or laparotomy (n = 21)
during 1997-98. In the second part 12 consecutive patients (all female, age
38, BMI 43 kg/m2) underwent HandPort assisted laparoscopic RGBP in an
open series during 1999. The stomach was always completely transected.
The Roux limb was made > 50 cm and brought to the proximal gastric
pouch (4 x 3 cm) behind the colon and the excluded stomach. In the first
part of the study the gastrojejunostomy was stapled with 30 mm linear
stapler and defects hand-sewn. In the second a circular stapler (no 21) was
used with the anvil introduced through a gastrotomy. The HandPort was
introduced through an 8 cm right subcostal incision. In the first part of the
study 7 patients (23%) had to be converted from laparoscopy to laparotomy
usually due to lack of proper exposure. The duration of surgery was
235 and 100 min, respectively (analysis with converted patients excluded).
The amount of morfin taken by PCA during postop day 1-3 was significantly
(p< 0,005) lower among laparoscopy patients (69 mg) in comparison
with patients in the open group (140 mg). Likewise, postoperative
hospital stay was shorter after laparoscopy (4 days), against 6 days after
laparotomy. Six laparoscopy patients had to be re-operated within one
month due to obstruction of the Roux limb at the level of the mesocolon.
In HandPort-assisted laparoscopy duration of surgery (including learning
curve time), amount of morfin and postoperative hospital stay were 207
min, 74 mg and 5 days, respectively. One patient (8 %) was converted to
laparotomy for safe closure of a small perforation of the proximal gastric
pouch caused by the anvil of the circular stapler. There were no cases of
early obstruction of the Roux limb. The expected benefits of laparoscopy
i.e. reduced postoperative pain and short hospital stay were confirmed.
However, conversions and obstruction of the Roux limb in _ of patients
indicate that the technique of laparoscopic RGBP has to be further improved
before it can be introduced into our clinical routine. HandPortassistance
may be such an improvement.
|