# 2316 Pain Management of Patients with Unresectable Periampullary
Carcinoma.
Rutger C. I. Geenen, Claudia M. G. Dekker, Gertjan Tienhoven,
Huug Obertop, Dirk J. Gouma, Amsterdam, Netherlands
Most patients (80-90%) with periampullary carcinoma are no candidate
for resection and need palliative treatment of symptoms, such as jaundice,
gastrointestinal obstruction and pain. Pain management is most commonly
performed by analgesics or a coeliac plexus block. Reduction of pain has
also been described after palliative radiotherapy for local tumor control.
The aim of this study was to analyze the effects of these different treatment
options for pain in patients who underwent a palliative surgical bypass for
unresectable periampullary carcinoma. The records of 98 patients, who
underwent a double bypass procedure (DBP) in the period between January
1995 and December 1998, were retrospectively reviewed. The patients
were divided in three groups according to initial pain management. Group
1 (n=27) underwent DBP and pain management by medication, group 2
(n=47) underwent DBP in combination with a peroperative coeliac plexus
block (PB) and group 3 (n=24) underwent DBP followed by high dose conformal
radiotherapy (RT). The tumor stages of the groups were not comparable,
because radiotherapy was not performed in patients with metastases
but only in an attempt to achieve local tumor control. Metastases were
present in respectively. 13/27(48%), 26/47(55%) and 0(0%) (p<0.01) patients.
There was no significant difference in patients with pre-existing pain
in the three groups respectively 15 (55%), 31 (66%) and 15 (63%). The
pain medication-free survival period after surgery was respectively 3.2, 3.3
and 7.5 months (NS). In the subgroup of patients with pre-existing pain
the pain medication-free survival was 3.2, 1.9 and 6.3 months (NS) and in
patients without pre-existing pain respectively 3.3, 6.5 and 9.3 months
(NS). Hospital-free survival was respectively 6.3, 6.8 and 10.3 months
(p=0.01). It is concluded that the positive effect of coeliac block on pain
from previous studies could not be confirmed and a suggested positive
effect on survival in the subgroup with pre-existing pain and coeliac block
was not found. The longest pain-medication-free survival and hospitalfree
survival was found in patients treated with radiotherapy. This effect is
probably mainly due to patient selection.
|